|
Altshuller took a large sample of patents from 14 different classes published in USSR
and analysed the levels of their invention. Altshuller made 5 different
levels of invention and classified those patents into those levels. The
distribution pattern of the sample patents in five different levels of
invention is as follows.
[The percentage of the inventions
in different levels are based on the study
made by Altshuller in 1982. The statistics may varry to some extent in
different sample of patents.]
1. The standard solution: this is typically a quantitative change without
new quality. Something like choosing between a few obvious alternatives. This
is done by using the knowledge within one's profession. Roughly 32% patented
solutions fall under this category.
Example: Additional function keys on a computer keyboard.
2. Change of a System: in this level of solution the object is changed
qualitatively but not substantially. This uses knowledge of the industry.
45% of patents fall under this level of invention.
Example: A fire extinguisher attached to a welding device.
3. Solution Across Industries: In this level of solution, the object
is radically changed. Not only the knowledge inside the industry, but knowledge
outside the industry is also used to bring this level of solution. About 19%
of the patented inventions fall under this category.
Example: Mouse as a pointing device in the computer.
4. Solutions Across Technology: A new object is created. The solution is
created not only the knowledge in the industry but also the knowledge of Science
and Technology. The solution is chosen out of tens of thousands of possible
variants. Only 4% of the patented solutions fall under this category.
Example: Integrated circuits, Personal Computer etc.
5. Discovery: In this level, the solution is based on a
scientific discovery. The solution is chosen from millions of possible
variants. Only 1% or less of the solutions fall under this category.
Example: Radio, watch, bicycle, aeroplane, photograpy etc.
| Level of invention |
Improvement |
Number of variants |
Knowledge used |
% of patents |
| 1. The standard solution |
trade-off, quantitative changes |
a few |
company knowledge |
32 % |
| 2. Change of a system |
qualitative change |
tens |
industry knowledge |
45 % |
| 3. Solution across industries |
radical or fundamental change
| hundreds |
knowledge across industries |
19 % |
| 4. Solution across sciences |
new system created |
thousands, tens of thousands |
knowledge across technology |
4 % |
| 5 Discovery |
breakthrough, new discovery |
hundreds of thousands, millions |
knowledge across science |
0.3 % |
Thus we find that most inventions are routine design solutions or
improvements to existing systems. There are very few inventions (less than 1%),
which are really scientific discoveries.
According to some TRIZ researchers, the recent patents are falling more
in the lower levels of invention. If we take a sample of recent patents,
"Solution across sciences" (4th level) and
"Scientific Discoveries" (5th level) are found to be very
neglegible in number.
|